Back to journal
Tech Employees

Exercise ISOs in December or January? How the AMT Timing Works

by Malik Amine

Key Takeaways

  • Exercising ISOs and holding the shares doesn't create regular income tax, but the spread (market value minus strike price) counts as income for the alternative minimum tax in the year you exercise.
  • For 2026 the AMT exemption is $140,200 for married couples filing jointly and $90,100 for single filers. It starts shrinking once AMT income passes $1 million ($500,000 single).
  • Exercising in December locks that spread into 2026. Exercising in January puts it in 2027, and you get the whole year to see where the stock goes before the tax is due.
  • If you sell the shares in the same calendar year you exercised, the sale is a disqualifying disposition. The spread becomes ordinary income, and the AMT adjustment for those shares goes away.
  • To get long-term capital gains treatment on ISO shares, you have to hold them more than two years from the grant date and more than one year from exercise.

The short version of how ISOs are taxed

An incentive stock option is the right to buy your company's stock at a fixed strike price. Under IRC §422, ISOs get better tax treatment than NSOs if you follow the rules.

When you exercise an ISO and keep the shares, there's no regular income tax at that moment. That's the good part. The catch is the alternative minimum tax, a parallel tax calculation that adds back certain items. The ISO spread is one of them. If the spread is big enough, your AMT can come out higher than your regular tax, and you pay the difference.

Here's a simple example. Your strike price is $5 and the stock is worth $45 when you exercise 2,000 shares. The spread is $40 a share, or $80,000. That $80,000 doesn't show up as wages, but it goes into the AMT calculation for that year.

Why the calendar matters

The AMT is figured year by year, so the year you exercise decides which return the spread lands on.

Exercising in December puts the spread on your 2026 return, due April 2027. If the stock drops a lot in January, you've already locked in AMT based on December's higher price, and it's too late to undo it with a same-year sale.

Exercising in January puts the spread on your 2027 return, due April 2028. You get about twelve months to watch the stock. If it falls sharply during 2027, you can sell before December 31, 2027, turn it into a disqualifying disposition, and pay ordinary income tax on the smaller actual gain instead of AMT on a spread that's gone.

Exercising early in a year also starts the one-year holding clock sooner. That's why a lot of people who plan ahead look at January exercises.

None of that means January is always better. If the company is private and the 409A value is about to jump after a new funding round, exercising before that can mean a much smaller spread. If you already have room under the AMT exemption this year, a December exercise might create little or no AMT. It depends on the numbers.

The numbers to check before you decide

  • Your AMT room this year. Many people can exercise some ISOs without owing AMT, because their regular tax is already higher than their AMT. The amount varies a lot. A CPA can run your return both ways and tell you roughly how much spread you can add before AMT kicks in.
  • The 2026 AMT exemption. $140,200 married filing jointly, $90,100 single, shrinking once AMT income passes $1 million or $500,000. The figures and their source are on the 2026 numbers page.
  • The $100,000 ISO limit. If more than $100,000 of ISOs (by grant-date value) become exercisable for the first time in one year, the excess is treated as NSOs. Your grant paperwork or equity platform usually shows which shares are which. See the ISO yearly limit.
  • The cash it takes. You pay the strike price to exercise, and possibly AMT the next April, while the shares might not be sellable yet.

If you've already exercised this year

If you exercised ISOs earlier in 2026 and the stock has fallen since, the same-year sale rule is worth knowing about before December 31. Selling those shares in 2026 makes it a disqualifying disposition. You'd owe ordinary income tax on the gain at sale (often smaller than the original spread), and the AMT adjustment for those shares goes away.

If you hold them into 2027, the AMT for 2026 is based on the spread at exercise, even if the stock is worth less by the time you file.

AMT you pay because of ISOs isn't always gone for good. It can create a minimum tax credit you may be able to use in later years when your regular tax is higher than your AMT. How fast you get it back depends on your future income.

If you're leaving the company

ISOs generally have to be exercised within three months of leaving your job to keep ISO treatment. After that, they're treated as NSOs if your plan lets you exercise later at all. If a job change is coming, the exercise deadline in your grant agreement is worth checking now.

What this doesn't cover

State tax, the net investment income tax, and early-exercise or 83(b) situations each change the math. This is general education, and the actual numbers need someone who can see your grant documents and your return.

Related notes